How many choices are too many?
Thursday, January 03, 2008
I recently bought a new car that came with a six-month subscription to a satellite radio service. I finally realized that I'd have to put money into the Dead Man's Cadillac and began to feel guilty about the carbon footprint the gas-guzzling tank of a car from the last century was leaving on the planet. But back to my story. Satellite radio service isn't something I'd ever buy on my own, as I prefer the predictability of CDs, and because I grew up with "free" radio and it's one of those things I don't think I should have to pay for.
Yet I am intrigued by the hundred or so options offered. I can listen to Springsteen 24/7. If I were a Parrothead, I could get Jimmy Buffett whenever I wanted. Want 70s soft rock? There's a channel for that. How about disco? Yep, you can get that, too. Or NFL, NHL, NBA or other league commentary. There's even stuff I can't mention here without violating our comments policy.
But I have to wonder if there's really an audience for all those options. I've enjoyed listening to the Martha Stewart Living interviews, but wonder who's listening (no offense to my Quixtar Canada friends) to the Iceberg Canadian rock station? Or to the New Age station? Or to Nancy Sinatra's weekly show?
Is more better? Or is more just more?
This is something we constantly struggle with here at Quixtar as we strive to support IBO businesses and introduce consumers to our products. Sometimes we've offered too many options for getting information and support and wound up creating confusion. Other times we've tried to simplify and eliminated options that some very vocal groups viewed as critical to their businesses.
We're about to launch an audit of all of our communications and look at them in two distinct categories -- communications that help IBOs do business and communications that help IBOs get consumers for our products. We've streamlined some of our communications -- I hope you've seen the new Achieve magazine that combines content from the old Achieve and What You Want magazines -- and are evaluating others.
Would a smaller, more focused portfolio of communications help your business? Or do you prefer more options and variety to meet the needs of your consumers? What's critical to keep and what's just clutter?
We're kicking off this effort in the coming weeks and would love to share some real IBO feedback with our team.